#267 Why Nonprofit Finance Is 10 Years Behind and How to Close the Gap with Ilana Esterrich, GrowCFO Mentor
Nonprofit finance often lags behind its for-profit counterpart due to structural funding constraints, donor reporting requirements, and historical expectations of finance as a back-office cost center rather than a strategy partner. This episode examines why nonprofit financial leadership is perceived to be about a decade behind and outlines concrete ways to modernize the CFO role—shifting from retrospective accounting to forward-looking strategy, donor partnership, and operational rigor that sustains mission at scale .
In this episode, Kevin Appleby hosts Ilana Esterrich, a GrowCFO Mentor and experienced nonprofit CFO, for a practical discussion on elevating nonprofit finance. Esterrich draws on a career spanning consulting, large corporates, and mission-driven organizations to explain how nonprofit finance must evolve from traditional, retroactive accounting to a strategic, value-creating function. She underscores that “no money, no mission,” and argues for disciplined investment in back-office capabilities—finance operations, legal, and technology—to build a foundation that enables programs to scale sustainably .
Kevin and Ilana discuss the growing expectations on nonprofit CFOs: scenario planning, interpreting donor intent, creative application of restricted funds, and partnering closely with development leaders. Esterrich also emphasizes people-centric leadership, shaped by her military background, and the importance of mentoring CFOs transitioning from “scorekeeper” to strategic leader. The conversation offers actionable insights for closing the perceived 10-year gap with for-profit finance, focusing on operational efficiency, stakeholder communication, and aligning finance with mission outcomes.
Key topics covered:
- “No money, no mission”: nonprofits need a growth mindset and disciplined investment in back-office foundations to scale programs responsibly
- Why nonprofit finance lags: CFO roles historically centered on backward-looking reporting versus forward-looking strategic architecture
- Closing the gap: scenario planning, clarity on donor intent, creative use of funds, and operational efficiencies that reduce the cost to raise a dollar
- Donor partnership: educating funders on the true cost of delivery and the need to resource “admin” to strengthen mission outcomes
- Evolving CFO leadership: influence beyond finance, managing larger teams, and aligning finance early with strategy discussions
- People-centric finance leadership: mission-first lessons from the military and mentoring the next generation of nonprofit CFOs
Links
Timestamps:
- 0:03:03 — “No money, no mission” and the case for investing in back office to strengthen program delivery
- 0:05:59 — Navigating donor-imposed admin limits and bringing donors into the operational reality
- 0:07:47 — CFO partnership with development and the shift toward direct donor engagement and reporting design
- 0:08:56 — Why nonprofit finance is ~10 years behind and the move from scorekeeping to strategic CFO
- 0:11:53 — Mentoring focus: helping CFOs become strategic value creators and people leaders
- 0:18:41 — Military-informed leadership principles applied to modern nonprofit finance teams
Find out more about GrowCFO
If you enjoyed this podcast, you can subscribe to the GrowCFO Show with your favorite podcast app. The GrowCFO show is listed in the Apple podcast directory, Spotify and many others. Why not subscribe there today? That way, you never miss an episode.
GrowCFO is a great place to extend your professional network. Join GrowCFO as a free member today and participate in our regular networking events and webinars. Premium members can also access our extensive training center and CFO Digital Toolkit. You can enroll in our flagship Future CFO or Finance Leader programs here.
You can find out more and join today at growcfo.net
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Responses